Intersexuality and Transgender Identity as a "Problem" of Participation in Sports Competitions
(Medical and Legal Aspects of Decision-Making Practice)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.46282/blr.2024.8.1.855Keywords:
Transgender Person, Intersexuality, Sex Determination Processes, Hyperandrogenism, Testosterone, Discrimination, „Very Weighty Reasons", Arbitration, European Court of Human RightsAbstract
Amidst a global landscape where transgender individuals face unprecedented challenges in accessing equitable sexual health care, our review breaks new ground by exploring the intricacies of sexual health within the transgender community. Unveiling the critical gaps in current health care practices, our research not only amplifies the voices of those often marginalised in health narratives but also pioneers a comprehensive, culturally sensitive approach to transgender sexual health. The literature review tries to find medical and subsequent legal justifications for PRO and CONS of participation of transgender and intersex athletes in the category of the opposite sex. It tries to analyse which differences in life can be relevant in defining competitive advantages, which nowadays lead to very controversial, often politically motivated conclusions. The opinions of the professional and sports public do not go along with some decisions of sports associations and authorities. It therefore also deals with the recent decision of the European Court of Human Rights in the case of Caster Semenya, as well as the participation of athletes across different sports disciplines and categories. It does not ignore the question of the adequacy of anti-discrimination measures. Furthermore, it evaluates the impact of such participation on the integrity and fairness of competitive sports, highlighting the need for a balanced approach that respects the rights of all athletes. This study stands at the forefront of transforming sexual health care for transgender individuals worldwide.
References
Coleman, D. L. (2017). Sex in Sport. Law and Contemporary Problems, 80(4), 63-126. Available at: https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/lcp/vol80/iss4/5 (accessed on 02.02.2024).
Coleman, D. L. and Shreve, W. (n.d.). Comparing Athletic Performances: The Best Elite Women to Boys and Men. In: Duke Law. Available at: https://law.duke.edu/sports/sex-sport/comparative-athletic-performance (accessed on 21.01.2024).
Dávid, L. (2012). Na hranicích práva. Soudcovské eseje. [On the Borders of the Law. Judge Essays]. Praha: Leges.
Hegge, A. M., Bucher, E., Ettema, G., Faude, O., Holmberg, H. C. and Sandbakk, Ø. (2016). Gender differences in power production, energetic capacity and efficiency of elite cross‑country skiers during whole‑body, upper‑body, and arm poling. European journal of applied physiology, 116(2), 291–300, https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-015-3281-y
Hilton, E. N. and Lundberg, T. R. (2021). Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage. Sports medicine, 51(2), 199–214, https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3
Kim, J. (2023). World chess just placed restrictions on both trans women and trans men. In: NPR, published on 18 August 2023. Available at: https://www.npr.org/2023/08/18/1194593562/chess-transgender-fide-pushback (accessed on 25.01.2024).
Liew, J. (2023). Dutch darts player will become first trans woman to play in a televised PDC tournament after long road back to a sport she loves. In: The Guardian, published on 14 July 2023. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2023/jul/14/noa-lynn-van-leuven-darts-interview (accessed on 10.01.2024).
Lipovietsky G. (1999). Soumrak povinnosti. Bezbolestná etika nových demokratických časů. [The Twilight of Duty. Painless Ethics of New Democratic Times]. Praha: Prostor.
Marshall, W. A. and Tanner, J. M. (1969). Variations in pattern of pubertal changes in girls. Archives of disease in childhood, 44(235), 291–303, https://doi.org/10.1136/adc.44.235.291
Marshall, W. A. and Tanner, J. M. (1970). Variations in the pattern of pubertal changes in boys. Archives of disease in childhood, 45(239), 13–23, https://doi.org/10.1136/adc.45.239.13
Medley, S. and Sherwin, G. (2019). Banning Trans Girls From School Sports Is Neither Feminist Nor Legal. In: ACLU, published on 12.03.2019. Available at: https://www.aclu.org/news/lgbtq-rights/banning-trans-girls-school-sports-neither-feminist-nor-legal (accessed on 21.01.2024).
Middleton, L. (2023). Trans athletes in sports: what´s the debate? In: Openlynews, published on 17 July 2023. Available at: https://www.openlynews.com/i/?id=3b588a4f-0564-4eb7-8afc-291e51eae543 (accessed on 25.01.2024).
O'Reilly, K. B. (2021). Raft of bills intrude on medical practice, harm transgender people. In: AMA-ASSN, published on 16 April 2021. Available at: https://www.ama-assn.org/delivering-care/population-care/raft-bills-intrude-medical-practice-harm-transgender-people (accessed on 21.01.2024).
Reed, E. (2023). Anti-Trans Activists Now Claim Trans Women Have An Advantage At Dart. In: Erin In The Morning, published on 05 December 2023. Available at: https://www.erininthemorning.com/p/anti-trans-activists-now-claim-women (accessed on 25.01.2024).
Reid, K. (2008). A Practioner´s Guide to the European Convention on Human Rights. Mytholmroyd: Sweet & Maxwell.
Roberts, T. A., Smalley, J. and Ahrendt, D. (2020). Effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance in transwomen and transmen: implications for sporting organisations and legislators. British journal of sports medicine, bjsports-2020-102329. Advance online publication. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2020-102329
Sandbakk, Ø., Solli, G. S. and Holmberg, H. C. (2018). Sex Differences in World-Record Performance: The Influence of Sport Discipline and Competition Duration. International journal of sports physiology and performance, 13(1), 2–8, https://doi.org/10.1123/ijspp.2017-0196
Strashin, J. (2023). Far from resolved: Debate rages following World Athletics' ban on trans athletes in elite female sport. In: CBC Sports, published on 25 March 2023. Available at: https://www.cbc.ca/sports/world-athletics-trans-ban-debate-1.6790454 (accessed on 02.01.2024).
Tidmas, V., Halsted, C., Cohen, M. and Bottoms, L. (2023). The Participation of Trans Women in Competitive Fencing and Implications on Fairness: A Physiological Perspective Narrative Review. Sports (Basel, Switzerland), 11(7), 133, https://doi.org/10.3390/sports11070133
Toomey, A. and Machado, B. (2015). Caitlyn Jenner Legally Changes Her Name and Gender. In: eonline.com, published on 25 September 2015. Available at: https://www.eonline.com/news/699992/caitlyn-jenner-legally-changes-her-name-and-gender (accessed on 12.06.2024).
Wipfler A. J. (2016). Identity Crisis: The Limitations of Expanding Government Recognition of Gender Identity and the Possibility of Genderless Identity Documents. Harvard Journal of Law and Gender, 39, 491–554.
Wood, R. I. and Stanton, S. J. (2012). Testosterone and sport: current perspectives. Hormones and behavior, 61(1), 147–155, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.yhbeh.2011.09.010
Yurcaba, J. (2024). Ohio Senate overrides governor’s veto of transgender care restriction. In: NBC News, published on 24 January 2024. Available at: https://www.nbcnews.com/nbc-out/out-politics-and-policy/ohio-senate-trans-sports medical-care-transition-minors-rcna135332 (accessed on 30.05.2024).
ABC news (2015). Bruce Jenner: 'I'm a Woman'. Published on 25 April 2015. Available at: https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/bruce-jenner-im-woman/story?id=30570350 (accessed on 12.06.2024).
Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR). What is gender? What is sex?. Available at: https://cihr-irsc.gc.ca/e/48642.html (accessed on 12.02.2024).
FIDE Regulations on Transgender Chess Players’ Registration on FIDE Directory. Available at: https://doc.fide.com/docs/DOC/2FC2023/CM2_2023_45.pdf (accessed on 10.01.2024).
IAAF Athletics (2018). Eligibility Regulations for the Female Classification (Athlets with Differences of Sex Development), published on 23 April 2018, coming into effect as from 1 November 2018. Available at: https://www.worldathletics.org/download/download?filename=2ff4d966-f16f-4a76-b387-f4eeff6480b2.pdf&urlslug=IAAF%20Eligibility%20Regulations%20for%20the%20Female%20Classification%20 (accessed on 21.01.2024).
LBTI women in sport: violence, discrimination, and lived experiences August 2021. Prepared by ILGA-Europe, a EuroCentralAsian Lesbian* Community (EL*C), TGEU, Organisation Intersex International Europe (OII Europe), and European Gay & Lesbian Sport Federation (EGLSF), published on 16 August 2021. Available at: https://www.ilga-europe.org/report/lbti-women-in-sport-violence-discrimination-and-lived-experiences/ (accessed on 28.05.2024).
Revision of the European Sports Charter. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/sport/revision-esc (accessed on 10.02.2024).
Sexuality and Gender Perspectives on Sports Ethics. In: Clearinghouse for Sports, updated on 02 February 2022. Available at: https://www.clearinghouseforsport.gov.au/kb/sexuality-and-gender-perspectives-on-sports-ethics#competitive_sport (accessed on 10.01.2024).
UN Expert warns Biden Administration: Rule changes in women & girls’ sports would breach “human rights obligations”. In: ADF International, published on 28.12.2023. Available at: https://adfinternational.org/news/un-expert-warns-against-us-rule-changes-in-womens-sports (accessed on 21.01.2024).
World Athletics Council decides on Russia, Belarus and female eligibility. In: World Athletics, published on 23 March 2023. Available at: https://worldathletics.org/news/press-releases/council-meeting-march-2023-russia-belarus-female-eligibility (accessed on 02.02.2024).
World Health Organization (WHO). Gender and health. Available at: https://www.who.int/health-topics/gender#tab=tab_1 (accessed on 12.02.2024).
CAS, Dutee Chand v. Athletics Federation of India (AFI) & The International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF), 2014/A/3759, 24 July 2015.
CAS, Mokgadi Caster Semenya v. International Association of Athletics Federations, 2018/O/5794, and Athletics South Africa v. International Association of Athletics Federations, 2018/O/5798, 30 April 2019.
CJEU, judgment of 30 April 1996, P v S and Cornwall County Council, C-13/94, ECLI:EU:C:1996:170.
CJEU, judgment of 7 January 2004, K.B. v National Health Service Pensions Agency and Secretary of State for Health, C-117/01, ECLI:EU:C:2004:7.
ECtHR, Marckx v. Belgium, app. no. 6833/74, 13 June 1979.
ECtHR, Van der Mussele v. Belgium, app. no. 8919/80, 23 November 1983.
ECtHR, Larkos v. Cyprus, app. no. 29515/95, 18 February 1999.
ECtHR, Christine Goodwin v. United Kingdom, no. 28957/95, 11 July 2002.
ECtHR, Semenya v. Swwitzerland, app. no. 10934/21, 11 July 2023.
Supreme Court of United States, United States v. Virginia et al., 518 U.S. 515 (1996).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Bratislava Law Review
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The Author(s) transfers copyright to the Article to the Publisher of the Journal by the Licence Agreement.
The Author(s) retains rights specified in the Licence Agreement.
The readers may read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of all of the Article of the Journal and use them for any other lawful purpose under specified Creative Commons Licence (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
How to Cite
