Organisational Nationalisation - Seizing Control of an Organisation without Transfers of Property Rights on the Example of Housing Cooperatives in People's Poland
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.46282/blr.2024.8.2.869Keywords:
Nationalisation, Housing Cooperatives, State Socialism, People’s Poland, Legal HistoryAbstract
In all Central and Eastern European countries during the period of the establishment of state socialism after World War II, nationalisation involving the state taking over ownership of certain categories of property in order to build an economic system in line with the new ideological principles took place. In Poland, large land estates, enterprises belonging to basic branches of the economy, or all real estate in the city of Warsaw were nationalised. The nationalisation of housing cooperatives contradicted the official declarations of the People's Poland authorities, who promised to support cooperative movement. However, a number of legal regulations were introduced with the help of which the People's Poland authorities took control over housing cooperatives in order to, at first, practically force them out of operation and, later, instrumentally use them to implement the state's housing policy. Centralisation of cooperative movement and hierarchical subordination of cooperatives to state-controlled associations were carried out. The economic activities of the housing cooperatives were subordinated to the principles of a centrally planned economy. The possibility of creating new cooperatives was restricted, and the authorities reserved the right to liquidate existing ones. The order in which cooperatives allocated housing to their members was superimposed. Later, cooperatives were forcibly merged, and the area in which they could operate was restricted. Cooperative self-government was partly transformed into local state administration. In the case of housing cooperatives in People's Poland we cannot speak of proper nationalisation because there were no transfers of ownership. However, all other effects of nationalisation took place, but were achieved by other means. Such measures can be described as organisational nationalisation, which was also carried out in other spheres in People's Poland.
References
Andrzejewski, A. (1979). Polityka mieszkaniowa [Housing Policy]. Warszawa: Państwowe Wydawnictwo Ekonomiczne.
Annuaire de l’Institut de droit international (1952). Vol. 44 II.
Chrzanowski, W. (1968). Aspekty prawne rozwoju spółdzielczości mieszkaniowej [Legal Aspects of the Development of Housing Cooperatives]. Nowe Prawo [The New Law], 3, 377-394.
Chrzanowski, W. (1973). Spółdzielczość mieszkaniowa w Polsce – problemy teorii i praktyki rozwoju [Housing Cooperative Movement in Poland - Problems of Theory and Practice of Development]. Spółdzielczy Kwartalnik Naukowy [Cooperative Scientific Quarterly], 27, 139-154.
Chyra-Rolicz, Z. (2002). Spółdzielczość w Polsce powojennej (1944-1990) [Cooperatives in Postwar Poland (1944-1990)]. Dzieje Najnowsze [Recent History], 1, 103-120.
Damşa, L. (2017). The Transformation of Property Regimes and Transitional Justice in Central Eastern Europe: In Search of a Theory. Cham: Springer.
Fermus-Bobowiec, A. (2019). Prawne instrumenty polityki mieszkaniowej w Polsce w latach 1944–1956 [Legal Instruments of Housing Policy in Poland in 1944-1956]. Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica, 18(2), 241-266.
Foighel, I. (1957). Nationalization: A Study in the Protection of Alien Property in International Law. London: Stevens.
Holečková, M. E., (2022). On Cooperative Housing in Socialist Czechoslovakia, 1959 – 1970. Architektúra & Urbanizmus, 3-4(56), 187-195.
Izdebski, H. (2011). Jednostki pomocnicze gminy-pomiędzy organami gminy a obywatelami jako podmiotem władzy lokalnej [Auxiliary Bodies of the Municipality- Between the Bodies of the Municipality and the Citizens as a Subject of Local Self-Government]. Samorząd Terytorialny [Local Self-Government], 12, 95-110.
Jarosz, D. (2010). Mieszkanie się należy… Studium z peerelowskich praktyk społecznych[Housing is Due... A Study in the Social Practices of Communist Society]. Warszawa: Aspra.
Kasperski, W. (1971). Problemy spółdzielczości mieszkaniowej 1956-1970 [Issues of Housing Cooperatives 1956-1970]. Warszawa: Zakład Wydawnictw CRS.
Kasperski, W. (1972). Spółdzielczość mieszkaniowa w Polsce [Housing Cooperative Movement in Poland]. Warszawa: Zakład Wydawnictw CRS.
Kovács, J. M. (2018). Expeditions to No Man’s Land. Comparing Economic Concepts of Ownership under Communism: An Evolutionary View. In: Kovács, J. M. (Ed.), Populating No Man’s Land: Economic Concepts of Ownership under Communism (pp. 287-339). Lanham-Boulder-New York-London: Lexington Books.
Kowalik, T. (1980). Spory o ustrój społeczno-gospodarczy Polski [Disputes over Poland's Socio-Economic System]. Warszawa: Niezależna Oficyna Wydawnicza NOWA.
Kuti, C. (2009). Post-Communist Restitution and the Rule of Law. Budapest: Central European University Press.
Lux, M., Cirman, A. and Sunega, P. (2017). Housing restitution policies among post-socialist countries: explaining divergence. International Journal of Housing Policy, 17(1), 145-156.
Madej, K. (2003). Spółdzielczość mieszkaniowa. Władze PRL wobec niezależnej inicjatywy społecznej (1961-1965) [Housing Cooperatives. People's Republic of Poland Authorities towards Independent Social Initiative]. Warszawa: Trio.
Maliszewski, A. (1992). Ewolucja myśli i społeczno-ekonomiczna rola spółdzielczości mieszkaniowej w Polsce [The Evolution of Thought and the Socio-Economic Role of Housing Cooperatives in Poland]. Warszawa: Spółdzielczy Instytut Badawczy.
Myczkowski, L. (1982). Nowa ustawa – prawo spółdzielcze (wstępne informacje i uwagi) [New Act - Cooperative Law (Preliminary Information and Remarks)]. Palestra, 11-12(299-300), 47-62.
Obradović, M. (2007). National Communism and Transformation of Ownership in Eastern Europe 1945–1952. Tokovi istorije, 4, 43-74.
Parusheva, D. and Marcheva, I. (2010). Housing in Socialist Bulgaria: Appropriating Tradition. Home Cultures, 7(2), 197-215.
Płocharski, J. (1979). Spółdzielczość mieszkaniowa w Polsce w latach 1945-1956 [Housing Cooperatives in Poland in the Years 1945-1956]. Warszawa: Zakład Wydawnictw CZSR.
Tymiński, M. (2018). From Soviet-Type Ownership through Self-Management to Privatization. In: Kovács, J. M. (Ed.), Populating No Man’s Land: Economic Concepts of Ownership under Communism (pp. 173-205). Lanham-Boulder-New York-London: Lexington Books.
Veress, E. (2022). Nationalization, Collectivization, Reprivatization and Privatization in East Central Europe: Arguments for a General Theory. In: Sáry, P. (Ed.), Lectures on East Central European Legal History (pp. 241-269). Miskolc: Central European Academic Publishing.
Act on people’s cooperatives and cooperative organisations, No. 53/1954 Coll.
Act on Cooperative Housing Construction, No. 27/1959 Coll.
Constitution of the People's Republic of Poland adopted by the Legislative Sejm on 22 July 1952 (Dz.U. 1952 nr 33 poz. 232).
Cooperative Law of 16 September 1982 (Dz.U. 1982 nr 30 poz. 210).
Decree of the Polish Committee for National Liberation of 6 September 1944 on the Implementation of Land Reform (Dz.U. 1944 nr 4 poz. 17).
Decree of the Polish Committee for National Liberation of 12 December 1944 on the Taking Over of Certain Forests to the Ownership of the State Treasury (Dz.U. 1944 nr 15 poz. 82).
Decree of 26 October 1945 on the Ownership and Use of Land in the Area of the Capital City of Warsaw (Dz.U. 1945 nr 50 poz. 279).
Decree of 26 October 1945 on the Demolition and Repair of Buildings Destroyed and Damaged by War (Dz.U. 1945 nr 50 poz. 281).
Decree of 8 March 1946 on Abandoned and Post-German Property (Dz.U. 1946 nr 13 poz. 87).
Decree of 26 April 1948 on the Department of Workers' Estates (Dz.U. 1948 nr 24 poz. 166).
Law of 29 October 1920 on Cooperatives, as amended (consolidated text: Dz.U. 1950 nr 25 poz. 232).
Law of 29 October 1920 on Cooperatives (Dz.U. nr 111 poz. 733).
Law of 3 January 1946 on the Takeover of Essential Branches of the National Economy into State Ownership (Dz.U. 1946 nr 3 poz. 17).
Law of 3 July 1947 on the Promotion of Construction (Dz.U. 1947 nr 52 poz. 270).
Law of 21 May 1948 on the Central Cooperative Union and Cooperative Headquarters (Dz.U. nr 30 poz. 199).
Law of 20 December 1949 amending the Law of 29 October 1920 on Cooperatives and the Law of 21 May 1948 on the Central Cooperative Union and Cooperative Headquarters (Dz.U. 1949 nr 65 poz. 524).
Law of 26 February 1951 on Newly Built or Rebuilt Buildings and Dwellings (Dz.U. 1951 nr 10 poz. 75).
Law of 28 May 1957 on the Exclusion from Public Management of Dwellings of Single-Family Houses and Dwellings in Houses of Housing Cooperatives (Dz.U. 1957 nr 31 poz. 131).
Law of 17 February 1961 on Cooperatives and their Associations (Dz.U. 1961 nr 12 poz. 61).
Downloads
Published
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Bratislava Law Review
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The Author(s) transfers copyright to the Article to the Publisher of the Journal by the Licence Agreement.
The Author(s) retains rights specified in the Licence Agreement.
The readers may read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of all of the Article of the Journal and use them for any other lawful purpose under specified Creative Commons Licence (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).
How to Cite
Funding data
-
Narodowe Centrum Nauki
Grant numbers 017/27/N/HS5/01168
